The Simple Concept That Few Understand

Social Security is one of those things that everyone knows about, but very few people understand the ins & outs of how it works.  It is a simple enough concept; every pay check the government takes money in the form of taxes, and then when we retire they give us that money back.  There is definitely more to it than that, but that is the very basic idea.

Towards the end of 2023, over 67 million people were receiving monthly Social Security benefits.  A little over three quarters of these beneficiaries are retirees and their families.  Other people that receive Social Security benefits include those with certain disabilities and dependents or spouses of certain workers who have died.  

For this dive into Social Security, the information discussed will pertain to the first group, retirees & their families.  While some of this information will carry over, the other groups are not something I specialize in and their details will not pertain to us today.

Social Security Eligibility

You qualify for Social Security by compiling credits every time you pay taxes on your earnings.  The exact tax is known as FICA, which stands for Federal Insurance Contributions Act.

You can earn up to four credits every year.  Once you reach a total of 40 credits over your lifetime, you are eligible to receive Social Security retirement benefits.

In 2024, $1,730 is the minimum amount of earnings that are eligible for a Social Security credit (this is the same amount that is required for a Medicare credit also).  For four credits in one year, you need to earn at least $6,920.  Earnings can be any form of compensation that require you to pay employment taxes

Over your lifetime, most people will earn more than the minimum fourty credits needed to qualify for Social Security retirement benefits.  These extra credits do not increase the benefit amount you will receive.  Instead, the average amount of your earnings is used to calculate your benefits, not the total number of credits earned.

No.  Social Security is an earned benefit, and you need to earn at least 40 credits over your lifetime to qualify for Social Security retirement benefits.

There are Social Security programs available for those that have not earned 40 credits, but they do not apply to the retirement benefits, and at least some amount of Social Security taxes needs to have been paid.

Yes.  There are two different groups of people that would fall in this category and they have different rules that apply to them.

Non-citizens living in the US may be eligible for Social Security if they 

  • are permanent legal residents
  • have visas that allow them to work in the US
  • were allowed in the country under US immigration law.

Undocumented immigrants who are residing in the US under the DACA program can get Social Security numbers, but will not reach the eligibility age for retirement benefits until the 2040s

Some undocumented immigrants do obtain fake Social Security numbers to get jobs.  These people pay billions of dollars each year into the Social Security system, but they rarely receive any benefits according to a Social Security report.  The money they pay ends up in a slush fund from which Social Security benefits are paid.

The other group is non-citizens living aboad.  These people may qualify for Social Security retirement benefits if they worked in the US and accrued enough credits.  Some of the requirements include being a citizen of a country with which the US has a Social Security agreement, living in the US for at least five years with a spouse who is an American citizen, or being married to someone who died during US military service.

Social Security credits are accounting units that you earn when you work and pay taxes.  Every pay check, the worker pays 6.2% of their income back as FICA taxes.  The employer pays the same amount.  If you are self employed, you will need to pay both parts.

In 2024, you earn one credit for every $1,730 you earn in wages or self-employement income.  If you earn $6,920 in a year you will receive four credits, which is the most that you can earn for that year.  You will need 40 credits qualify for Social Security retirement benefit, though the threshold varies slightly for other benefit types.

You need 40 credits to receive Social Security retirement benefits.  You can only obtain a maximum of four per year.  If you work for ten years, earning at least $6,920 each year, you will qualify for Social Security retirement benefits.

In most cases, no.  You can receive both a military pension and Social Security retirement benefits.

The exception to this may be if you receive supplemental security income (SSI), which is only available to those below a certain income level.

Most people working today pay into the Social Security system via payroll or self-employment taxes, enabling them to be covered by Social Security.

Those that do not pay into Social Security (and therefore are not eligible ro receive Social Security retirement benefits) include

  • People that work for some state, county, & municipals that are instead covered by state-funded pension plans
  • Railroad employees who are covered by railroad pension
  • Employees of the US government who were hired before 1984 who instead receive a pension under the Civil Service Retirement System
  • Certain US citizens who work for foreign governments (such as an American working at another country’s embassy here in the US).

While these specific jobs to not pay into the Social Security system, if the people working these jobs have accumulated enough credits to qualify for Social Security, they will receive Social Security retirement benefits, though the amount they receive may be reduced.

Social Security Benefits

You should apply no later than the month in which you want your benefits to start.  You can file up to four month before that, giving Social Security enough time to process your application.  The minimum age that you can collect retirement benefits is 62.  The earliest you can apply is when you reach 61 years and 9 months.

Regardless of how far ahead you file, you will not receive your first payment until the month after your first full month as a 62 year old (Social Security is always one month behind, so you’re January benefits will be received in February, your February benefits in March, and so on).

Keep in mind, that if you have already filed for Social Security benefits, your Medicare will automatically kick in when you turn 65 unless you chose to opt out.

The earliest that you can start collecting is age 62. However, your benefit amount will be reduced if you start collecting before full retirement age (FRA).

Full retirement age for people born before 1954 is 66.  If you were born in 1960 or later, your full retirement age is 67.  People born in between those years have their retirement age gradually increased from 66 to 67.

*Important* Even though the full retirement age is over 65, you should still consider applying for Medicare benefits prior to your 65th birthday.  Waiting longer may cost you money.

Yes.  If you have reached your full retirement age but are not yet 70 years old, you can request that your retirement benefits be suspended.

During suspension, you earn delayed retirement credits which boost your eventual benefit by 8% for each year they are suspended (the actual amount is 0.66% monthly, so you do not need to go an entire year to see the benefit increase).  When you resume collecting Social Security, you will be locked in at a higher monthly benefit for life.

You can resume your benefits anytime before you turn 70.  If you have not resumed them by then, they will automatically reinstate at the higher amount.

If you have not reached FRA, you may request a ‘withdraw of benefits.’  This is a bit more complicated than the suspension of benefits above and requires you to repay the Social Security benefits that you have already collected.

Keep in mind, that this suspension only applies to retirement benefits.

Yes.  There are a few things that can change the benefit amount you receive each month.

  • Benefit amount are recalculated each October to account for inflation.  These changes take effect the following January.
  • If you make income over a certain limit, while also drawing benefits, your benefit amount may be reduced.
  • If you suspend your benefits, you can accumulate delayed retirement credits which increase the future benefits.
  • Your Social Security benefits can be offset if you owe money to the government.  Reasons for this could be from defaulted student loan, food stamp overpayment corrections, home loans owed to the VA, or back taxes (this is technically a levy, but the concept is similar).
  • If your Medicare premiums change.  Medicare premiums for your Part-B are taken directly from your Social Security benefits.  When the monthly premium for this changes, which can happen for a few reasons, your benefit amount will also change.

Your retirement benefit is based on your lifetime earnings on which you paid FICA taxes.  Higher income means a bigger benefit, up to a certain limit.  Your benefit amount is modified by a few factors, most importantly of which is the age at which you claim the benefits.

The estimated average retirement benefit is $1,907 a month.  The maximum you can receive is $3,822 a month.  You can only be sure of the amount you will receive when you apply, but there are ways to get an idea.  The easiest is to check online at your Social Security account.  This pulls from your earnings recorded on file to give a sense of what you will be receiving.  Keep in mind that this number may change as you continue to work and will be adjusted depending on when you chose to start receiving your benefits.

To give a ballpark figure, if you were born in 1962 and averaged $50,000 annual income, never married, and filed to receive benefits starting your 62nd birthday, you would receive $1,386 each month. At FRA, you would receive $1,980.  At age 70 you would receive $2,455.

Remember, Social Security caps how much you can receive.  After a certain amount your income is neither counted towards your earnings average nor is it taxed. In 2024 this cap is $168,600.

Yes and no.  The single largest factor to the benefit amount that you will receive is based on how old you are when you retire.  You can elect to receive benefits as early as 62 and as late as 70, at which point you will begin receiving benefits automatically.  Remember, that deferring your benefits past your FRA will increase the amount by 0.66% per month, or 8% per year, which can mean the difference between maintaining your quality of life in retirement and having to cut back on certain expenditures.

The other factor to consider is that, if you are younger than your FRA, drawing benefits, and still working, Social Security will deduct a portion of your benefits if your earnings exceed a certain limit.  This limit is adjusted annually and it differs depending on how close you are to your FRA.

In 2024, at one year away from FRA, the earnings limit is $22,320.  $1 will be deducted from your benefits for every $2 earned over this cap.  So, if you have a part time job earning $30,000 a year, $7,680 over the limit, your Social Security benefits will be reduced by $3,840.

For the calendar year you reach FRA, the earnings limit is $59,520, with $1 in benefits withheld for every $3 earned over that limit.  Once you reach your FRA month, you will no longer have your benefits reduced regardless of your income and will instead have your benefits increased to recoup what you had lost due to the prior withholding.

Keep in mind that this earning cap only applies to income from work.  It does not count investments, pension, capital gains, or annuities.

Yes, most of the time.  You will still need to qualify by having 40 credits, and live in a country that not under Treasure Department sanctions (this currently only applies to Cuba & North Korea).  There are a few other countries where you can receive benefits, but only under strict conditions such as appearing personally to the US embassy every six months.

The rules are a bit different for non-US citizens who qualify when living abroad and depend on their country of citizenship.

For most people, Medicare eligibility starts at age 65.  If you are already receiving Social Security retirement benefits, the SSA will send you a Medicare enrollment package at the beginning of your initial enrollment period, which is 3 months before the month you turn 65.

At age 65, you will automatically be enrolled in parts A & B, though you can opt out of Part B if you wish.  Just ensure that you will not receive penalties if you do so.

Your Medicare Part-B premiums are automatically removed from your Social Security benefits each month.  If you are instead enrolled in Medicare Part-C or Part-D, you have the option to have the premium deducted from your Social Security benefit or to pay the plan provider directly.  I you want to pay your provider directly, you will need to contact the provider to arrange it.

If you have already enrolled in Medicare, but have not begun drawing your retirement benefits, you will instead receive bills from CMS.  There is no change to the monthly premiums for having a bill sent to you as opposed to having it pulled directly from your Social Security retirement benefits.

 

Yes, but only if you are over FRA.

If you chose to not apply for Social Security benefits until five months past your FRA, you can also chose to receive retroactive benefits in a lump sum for that number of months.  If you file six months or more past FRA, you can receive up to six months in back benefits.

You cannot collect retroactive payments if you suspended your benefits.  Additionally, receiving any lump sum benefit will cause the loss of delayed retirement credits for the months you chose to claim (up to 4% for a six month retroactive payment)

Work Income, Pensions, & Retirement Age

Yes.  There is a penalty to doing this however and the penalty is determined by your age and how much income you earn.

Up until the year of your full retirement age, every $2 you earn over a cap of $22,320 will cause a loss of $1 from your Social Security retirement benefits.

The year of your FRA, this penalty changes to $1 per every $3 earned over a cap of $59,520.  Past the month of your birthday in the year of your full retirement age, you will no longer have any penalties on your income.

Remember, that this penalty only applies to income earned.  Investments, pensions, capital gains, or annuities do not count towards income.

Yes.  Jobless benefits are not counted as wages under Social Security’s earning limits.  Most states have also done away with the practice of deducting money from unemployment benefits if you receive Social Security benefits.

No.  Your spouse’s earning history does not interact with your Social Security retirement benefits, even if you filing jointly. Your spouse continuing to work will also not change your benefit amount.

However, your spouse’s earnings may affect the total amount you receive from Social Security if you receive spousal benefits.

There are two images below.  The first shows your full retirement age (FRA) based on the year you were born.  The second image shows the adjustment to your Social Security retirement benefits based on the year start using these benefits.

Full Retirement AgeSocial Security Benefit Adjustment by Age

Delayed retirement credits are a financial reward given to those that put off claiming their retirement benefits.  These credit start accumulating the month you hit your FRA.

Every month from your FRA until age 70 that you do not file for benefits, your eventual benefit increased by 0.66%, or 8% per year.

For example, if your full retirement age is 67 but you do not claim benefits until age 70, you will receive an extra 24% on your monthly payment.

These credits do not accumulate past age 70.  While you may file later than that, it will not increase your benefit amount.  

62, however starting your retirement benefits at this age will come with a penalty.

No.  Only earned income, or wages from a job (or net earnings from self-employement) count against your earning limit.

At the same time, contributions cannot be deducted from your income in regards to the earnings test.  Social Security uses your gross income before tax-deferred allotments to determine your earnings.

Probably not, at least not for the vast majority of people.  If your employer withheld FICA taxes from your paychecks (which most do) then your pension will not affect your Social Security retirement benefits in any way.

There are a few times where people did not have FICA withholding but earned pensions.  In this case, a different formula is used to calculate the FRA benefit amount.  The end result is normally lower, but never $0.

No.  You can receive both a military pension and Social Security retirement benefits at the same time without one adjusting the other’s benefit amount.

The rare exception to this is if you also receive Supplemental Security Income (SSI).  This is meant for people who are low income and also disabled, blind, or older than 65.  You are unable to collect SSI if your overall income (both military pension & retirement benefits) exceed a certain income limit. 

Still have questions? Schedule a time to talk or send us a message.

Aaron
Latest posts by Aaron (see all)

Solverwp- WordPress Theme and Plugin

Scroll to Top